Home Articles Business Advice

Sole Trader vs Limited Company: 9 Proven Factors to Help You Choose in 2026/27

  • LPA Accountancy
  • 12 min read
Sole trader vs limited company decision

Key takeaways

  • A sole trader is simple and cheap to run; you pay income tax and Class 4 National Insurance on all profits.
  • A limited company pays corporation tax at 19% to 25%, and you take income as salary and dividends.
  • A company protects personal assets with limited liability, but has more paperwork and public filings.
  • Higher profits, retained profits and higher Scottish tax rates usually tip the balance towards a company.
  • You can start as a sole trader and incorporate later when the numbers support it.

Sole trader vs limited company is one of the first big decisions when you start working for yourself, and one of the most common questions we answer at LPA Accountancy. Both are legal and both work well. The right choice depends on your profits, your plans, the risks in your work and how much admin you are happy to take on.

This guide compares the two structures for the 2026/27 tax year, including the Autumn Budget 2026 changes, so you can make the decision with confidence. It is written for new and growing businesses in Glasgow, across Scotland and throughout the UK.

Sole trader vs limited company for Glasgow businesses
Glasgow businesses choose between sole trader and limited company every day.

Sole trader vs limited company: the key difference

As a sole trader, you and the business are the same legal person. You keep all the profit after tax, and you are personally responsible for all of the business’s debts.

A limited company is a separate legal person, registered at Companies House. It owns its money and contracts, pays its own tax, and you are a director and shareholder. Its debts are normally the company’s, not yours.

Everything else in the sole trader vs limited company comparison flows from that one difference: how tax is charged, how you take money out, what you must file, and what is public.

How each structure is taxed in 2026/27

Sole traderLimited company
Tax on profitsIncome tax on all profits at your rate (Scottish rates if you live in Scotland)Corporation tax: 19% up to £50,000, 25% above £250,000, marginal relief between
National InsuranceClass 4: 6% on profits £12,570 to £50,270, 2% aboveEmployee and employer NI on salary only; none on dividends
Taking money outDraw any amount; tax is on profit, not drawingsSalary through payroll and dividends from taxed profits
Dividend taxNot applicable£500 allowance, then 10.75%, 35.75% or 39.35%
Keeping profit in the businessTaxed in full every yearOnly corporation tax until you take it out

The last row matters most for growing businesses. A sole trader pays income tax on every pound of profit, even money left in the business account. A company pays corporation tax only, so profits you reinvest are taxed at a lower rate.

Since 6 April 2024 Class 2 National Insurance is no longer compulsory for the self-employed, although you can pay it voluntarily to protect your State Pension record if your profits are low.

When a limited company usually makes sense

There is no single profit figure that settles sole trader vs limited company for everyone. In our experience, a company often starts to make sense when one or more of these apply:

  • your profits are consistently above the higher-rate threshold, or are heading that way;
  • you want to leave profits in the business to grow, buy equipment or build reserves;
  • your clients prefer, or insist on, working with a limited company;
  • your work carries real risk, such as large contracts, staff or premises;
  • you plan to bring in a partner, investor or family shareholder;
  • you want to make large pension contributions through the business.

If you are a contractor, IR35 also affects the answer. Read our IR35 guide and our comparison of umbrella company vs limited company.

Want the numbers for your business?

Tell us your expected profit and we will show you sole trader vs limited company tax side by side, free and with no obligation. Call or WhatsApp 0330 043 6250.

Get a fixed-fee quoteWhatsApp 0330 043 6250
Sole trader vs limited company tax comparison
Run the figures for your own profits before you decide.

When staying a sole trader is better

For many people, sole trader is the right answer, at least to start with. It usually suits you if:

  • profits are modest, or you are testing an idea;
  • you need all of the profit to live on, so there is little to retain;
  • you want the least possible paperwork and cost;
  • you value privacy, because sole traders do not appear on a public register;
  • your work is low risk and covered by insurance.

From 6 April 2027 the trading allowance rises from £1,000 to £3,000, so very small side businesses may not need to register at all. Our guide to accounting for freelancers covers the basics of running as a sole trader.

Running costs of each structure

Tax is only part of the sole trader vs limited company picture. Running costs come straight off any saving.

Sole trader

Bookkeeping software, an accountant for the tax return if you want one, and insurance. A separate bank account is sensible but not legally required.

Limited company

A business bank account, Companies House fees, accountancy for accounts, corporation tax and payroll, insurance, and your own Self Assessment return as a director.

Time

A sole trader can spend a few hours a year on admin. A company needs a monthly routine for bookkeeping, payroll and dividend paperwork.

When we compare sole trader vs limited company for a client, we always show the saving after these costs. A tax saving of a few hundred pounds can disappear once higher accountancy fees and extra admin time are included.

Image, credibility and winning work

Some customers, especially larger businesses, public bodies and recruitment agencies, prefer to work with limited companies. A company name, registered office and company number can make a small business look more established.

That said, plenty of successful tradespeople, consultants and creatives work as sole traders for their whole careers. You can trade under a business name as a sole trader too, as long as it is not misleading and does not include “Limited” or “Ltd”.

If a key client will only contract with a company, that can settle the sole trader vs limited company question for you, whatever the tax position.

Admin, filings and deadlines compared

Sole traderLimited company
RegistrationRegister with HMRC for Self Assessment by 5 October after your first tax yearIncorporate at Companies House, verify directors’ identity, register for corporation tax and PAYE
Annual filingsSelf Assessment return by 31 JanuaryAnnual accounts, corporation tax return, confirmation statement and directors’ Self Assessment
Quarterly reportingMaking Tax Digital for Income Tax if qualifying income is over £50,000 (£30,000 from April 2027)Not in MTD for Income Tax; MTD for VAT if registered
PayrollNot needed unless you employ staffUsually needed for directors’ salary
Public informationNoneName, registered office, directors, shareholders and accounts are public

See our Self Assessment deadlines guide for sole trader dates, and our company tax return guide for company filings.

Limited liability: how much protection do you get?

Limited liability means that if the company cannot pay its debts, your personal assets such as your home are normally protected. Your loss is limited to what you put into the company.

In practice, the protection has limits. Banks and landlords often ask directors for personal guarantees. Directors can become personally liable for wrongful or fraudulent trading, unpaid taxes in some cases, and overdrawn directors’ loan accounts. Good insurance is still important.

As a sole trader you have unlimited liability, so business debts are your personal debts. For low-risk service businesses with professional indemnity and public liability insurance, this is often a manageable risk.

Taking money out of a limited company

This is where many new directors trip up in the sole trader vs limited company switch. The company’s money is not yours until you pay it to yourself correctly.

  1. Salary through payroll, often set at a level that protects your State Pension record with little or no National Insurance.
  2. Dividends, which can only be paid from profits after corporation tax, with proper paperwork.
  3. Expenses repaid for genuine business costs you paid personally.
  4. Employer pension contributions, which are usually deductible for corporation tax.

Anything else you take is a loan from the company. If a director’s loan is still outstanding nine months after the year end, the company pays a temporary tax charge of 33.75% on it, and benefit-in-kind rules can apply. We set up a simple monthly plan so this never happens.

Mortgages, pensions and personal finances

Mortgages. Lenders normally want two years of figures. For sole traders they use your tax calculations. For directors, many use salary plus dividends, and some use your share of company profit. Incorporating just before a mortgage application can complicate things, so time it carefully.

Pensions. Sole traders get tax relief on personal pension contributions. Companies can make employer contributions, which save corporation tax and carry no National Insurance, making them very efficient for directors.

Income stability. As a sole trader, tax follows profit year by year. A company lets you smooth your income, taking similar amounts each year even when profits rise and fall, which can keep you out of higher tax bands.

6 mistakes to avoid when choosing

  1. Choosing on tax alone. The sole trader vs limited company decision also involves risk, admin, privacy and your plans.
  2. Using old rates. Dividend tax went up in April 2026, and online calculators are not always updated.
  3. Forgetting Scottish rates. UK-wide examples understate the tax on sole trader profits in Scotland.
  4. Treating company money as your own. This creates director’s loans and unexpected tax.
  5. Incorporating too early. A company in its first year of low profits often costs more than it saves.
  6. Not getting advice. A short review of your figures usually gives a clear answer.

Reviewing the sole trader vs limited company question once a year, when your accounts are prepared, is a good habit. Profits change, and so does the best structure.

Sole trader vs limited company in Scotland

Scottish taxpayers pay higher income tax than the rest of the UK on most earnings above about £31,000, and the Scottish advanced and top rates are higher still. Sole trader profits are taxed at these Scottish rates.

Dividends and corporation tax are set UK-wide, so they are the same in Glasgow as in London. This means the sole trader vs limited company calculation often favours a company at a lower profit level in Scotland than in England. Check the current bands in our Scottish income tax rates guide.

What about partnerships and LLPs?

If you are going into business with someone else, the sole trader vs limited company choice gains two more options.

An ordinary partnership works like two or more sole traders sharing a business. Each partner pays income tax and Class 4 National Insurance on their share of the profits, and the partnership files its own tax return as well as each partner’s return. In Scotland, a partnership is a separate legal person, but partners are still personally liable for its debts.

A limited liability partnership (LLP) gives members limited liability, like a company, while profits are still taxed on the members as if they were self-employed. LLPs are common for professional firms but less so for small trading businesses.

For two founders who want to grow and keep profits in the business, a limited company with two shareholders is often simpler. Shareholders’ agreements set out who owns what and what happens if one of you leaves. If you are weighing up a partnership against the sole trader vs limited company options, talk to us before you register anything, because changing structure later can create extra tax and paperwork.

Switching from sole trader to limited company

Many businesses start as sole traders and incorporate later. Done properly, the switch is smooth:

1. Plan the date

Pick a clean date, often the start of a month or quarter, and tell customers and suppliers.

2. Set up the company

Incorporate, verify identities, open a business bank account and register for taxes.

3. Transfer the business

Move equipment, contracts and, where appropriate, goodwill, with advice on capital gains and VAT.

4. Close the sole trade

Tell HMRC you have stopped, file a final Self Assessment return and plan for the cessation tax.

5. Run the company

Set up payroll, bookkeeping, dividends and a filing calendar from day one.

LPA Accountancy can set up your company and handle every step of the transfer.

Autumn Budget 2026: what changes

The Budget on 28 October 2026 left the main rates of income tax, National Insurance, corporation tax and dividend tax unchanged for 2027/28. The changes that affect the sole trader vs limited company decision are:

  • the trading allowance rising from £1,000 to £3,000 from 6 April 2027;
  • the Business Asset Disposal Relief lifetime limit falling from £1 million to £500,000 from 6 April 2027, which affects the tax when you sell or close a company;
  • planned changes to how company distributions are taxed from April 2028, with details still to come.

Rates and thresholds are confirmed each year on GOV.UK.

How LPA Accountancy can help you choose

LPA Accountancy works with sole traders and limited companies across Glasgow, Scotland and the UK. We will:

  • compare sole trader vs limited company tax using your real figures;
  • explain the admin each option involves;
  • register you as self-employed or set up your company;
  • run your bookkeeping, payroll, VAT and returns for a fixed fee.

See our sole trader packages and limited company packages, or book a free 15-minute consultation.

Frequently asked questions

Is it better to be a sole trader or a limited company?

It depends on your profits, plans and risk. Sole trader is simpler and cheaper to run. A limited company usually saves tax at higher profits, especially when you keep money in the business, and limits your personal liability.

At what profit should I become a limited company?

There is no fixed figure. A company often starts to make sense when profits are consistently around or above the higher-rate threshold, or when you want to retain profits. In Scotland it can make sense at slightly lower profits.

Can I change from sole trader to limited company later?

Yes. Many businesses incorporate after a year or two. You set up the company, transfer the business, and file a final Self Assessment return for the sole trade.

Do limited companies pay less tax?

Often, but not always. Corporation tax plus dividend tax can be lower than income tax and Class 4 National Insurance on the same profit, but company running costs reduce the saving.

Is a sole trader the same as self-employed?

Yes. A sole trader is a self-employed person who runs their own business and pays tax through Self Assessment.

Do I need an accountant for a limited company?

It is not a legal requirement, but most directors use one because of the accounts, corporation tax return, payroll and director duties involved.

Talk to LPA Accountancy

Call or WhatsApp 0330 043 6250 any time, or send us a message. We reply to emails within 24–72 hours and quote fixed fees in writing before any work starts.

Contact usFree consultation

Last updated 18 November 2026 by the LPA Accountancy team. This article gives general information, not personal advice; please speak to us about your own circumstances.

Live Chat