Guide · Updated 18 November 2026 · Contractors and clients
IR35 Explained: A Guide for Contractors and Clients
IR35, or the off-payroll working rules, decides whether a contractor working through their own limited company should be taxed like an employee. This IR35 guide explains who decides status, the tests that matter, what happens inside and outside IR35, how to challenge a determination, and how to protect your take-home pay.
- AML supervised
- HMRC tax agent
- Companies House ACSP
- Xero · QuickBooks · FreeAgent · Dext · IRIS
The basics
What is IR35?

IR35 is the name commonly used for the rules that apply when someone provides their services through an intermediary, usually their own limited company, but would be an employee if they were engaged directly. When IR35 applies, the contractor pays broadly the same income tax and National Insurance as an employee on the income from that engagement, even though they are paid through a company.
The rules exist because a contractor paid through a company can otherwise take a small salary and dividends, which usually costs less in tax than employment income. HMRC’s view is that people working like employees should pay tax like employees. The rules do not stop anyone working through a company; they change how the income from a particular contract is taxed.
Who decides
Who decides IR35 status?
| End client | Who decides status | Who deducts tax if inside |
|---|---|---|
| Public sector body (any size) | The client | The fee-payer (usually the agency or client) |
| Medium or large private sector business | The client | The fee-payer |
| Small private sector business | The contractor’s own company | The contractor’s company, through a deemed payment |
Whether a private sector client is small is based on the Companies Act tests for turnover, balance sheet total and number of employees. Where the client decides, it must give you a status determination statement explaining its conclusion and reasons, and it must take reasonable care in reaching it. Clients outside the UK with no UK presence are usually exempt from these duties.
The tests
The tests that decide IR35 status
Control
Does the client decide what, how, when and where you work, or do you?
Substitution
Can you genuinely send someone else to do the work, and has that right been used?
Mutuality of obligation
Is the client obliged to offer work, and are you obliged to accept it?
Financial risk
Do you fix mistakes at your own cost, invest in equipment or risk losing money?
Part and parcel
Are you integrated into the organisation like an employee, managing staff or using staff perks?
Business on own account
Do you have several clients, market your services and run a genuine business?
No single factor decides the answer. Courts look at the whole picture, and the actual working practices matter as much as the written contract. HMRC’s Check Employment Status for Tax tool gives a view on many cases, and HMRC will stand by the result if the information given is accurate. Find it on GOV.UK.
Inside IR35
What happens if a contract is inside IR35?
When a medium or large client decides an engagement is inside IR35, the fee-payer deducts income tax and employee National Insurance from your fees before paying your company, and pays employer National Insurance and, where relevant, the apprenticeship levy on top. Your company receives the net amount, which is not taxed again as company income when you draw it out. However, you lose the tax advantages of salary and dividends on that income, and expenses such as travel to the client’s site are usually no longer deductible.
Many contractors with inside IR35 roles consider whether it is still worth keeping their company, or whether an umbrella company or a direct employment contract would be simpler. The right answer depends on whether you also have outside IR35 work, your other income and your plans.
Outside IR35
Working outside IR35
If an engagement is outside IR35, your company is paid gross and you can use the normal approach for a limited company: a modest salary, dividends from post-tax profits, employer pension contributions and legitimate business expenses. An outside IR35 determination is not permanent, though. If your working practices change during the contract, for example if you start managing the client’s staff or the client begins to control how you work, the status may change too. Keep evidence of how you actually work, review status whenever a contract is extended or changed, and keep a copy of every status determination statement.
Disagreeing
How to challenge an IR35 determination
- 1
Read the SDS
Check the reasons given and whether they reflect how you actually work.
- 2
Gather evidence
Contracts, emails, examples of substitution, your own equipment and other clients.
- 3
Write to the client
Use the client-led disagreement process, setting out why you disagree.
- 4
Get a response
The client must respond within 45 days, either confirming or changing its decision.
We review status determination statements, help you prepare a clear and evidenced case, and explain the financial effect of each outcome so you can decide whether to challenge, renegotiate your rate or look for another role.
For clients
IR35 for businesses that engage contractors
Medium and large businesses that engage contractors through intermediaries must decide status for each engagement, issue status determination statements, take reasonable care, operate a disagreement process and keep records. If the client fails in these duties, it can become the fee-payer and be liable for the tax. Many businesses take a blanket approach and treat all contractors as inside IR35, which is simpler but can make it harder to attract the best people and may cost more. A role-by-role assessment, documented properly, is usually the better approach. We can help businesses set up a sensible process and review individual roles.
Background
How the off-payroll working rules developed
The original rules were introduced in 2000 and required contractors themselves to decide whether each engagement should be taxed like employment. Compliance was low, so the Government moved responsibility to the client: first for public sector bodies from April 2017, and then for medium and large private sector businesses from April 2021. Small private sector clients were left out to reduce their administrative burden, which is why contractors working for small businesses still make their own assessment. Since April 2024, where HMRC finds that the wrong decision was made, it can offset tax already paid by the contractor and their company against the amount due from the fee-payer, reducing the risk of the same income being taxed twice.
Small clients
When your own company makes the decision
If your client is a small private sector business, your own company must decide whether the rules apply to each engagement. If it decides the work would be employment, the company calculates a deemed employment payment at the end of the tax year and pays PAYE and National Insurance on it. The calculation allows a flat 5% deduction for running costs, plus salary already paid and certain expenses. Getting this wrong can lead to tax, interest and penalties years later, so it is important to document your reasoning for each contract and keep it with your records. We help contractors with small clients assess each engagement and, where necessary, calculate the deemed payment correctly.
Contracts
What to look for in a contract
- A genuine right of substitution, with no requirement for the client’s consent beyond reasonable checks on skills.
- A defined project or deliverables, rather than an open-ended role.
- Payment for results or milestones rather than simply for time.
- Freedom over how, when and where you work, within the needs of the project.
- Responsibility for correcting your own mistakes at your own cost.
- No obligation on the client to offer further work, or on you to accept it.
- No access to employee benefits, line management of staff or inclusion in staff appraisals.
A well-drafted contract helps, but it must match reality. HMRC and the tribunals look at how the engagement actually works, so make sure your day-to-day practices are consistent with what the contract says.
Take-home pay
Planning your take-home pay
An inside determination can reduce take-home pay significantly for the same day rate. Before accepting a role, compare what you would keep inside and outside the rules, through your company, through an umbrella company and on a fixed-term employment contract. Factor in pension contributions, holiday, expenses, the cost of running a company and the risk of gaps between contracts. Many contractors negotiate a higher rate for inside roles to reflect the extra cost. We prepare a simple comparison for any role you are considering, using your actual rate and circumstances, including Scottish income tax if you live in Scotland.
Next step
IR35 reviews and contractor accounting
We review contracts and status determinations, run your limited company accounts, payroll and dividends, file your tax returns and plan your pay around each contract. Fees are fixed and agreed before we start.
FAQs
IR35 FAQs
What is IR35?
The off-payroll working rules that tax contractors working through their own company like employees when the engagement would be employment if direct.
Who decides IR35 status?
Public sector bodies and medium or large private sector clients decide. For small private sector clients, the contractor’s own company decides.
What is a status determination statement?
A document from the client giving its IR35 decision for an engagement and the reasons for it.
Can I challenge an inside IR35 decision?
Yes. Use the client-led disagreement process; the client must respond within 45 days.
Can I claim travel expenses inside IR35?
Usually not for engagements inside IR35 where the fee-payer deducts tax.
Does IR35 apply to sole traders?
No. It applies where you work through an intermediary such as your own limited company.
Related services
Other services from LPA Accountancy
Get in touch
Worried about IR35?
Call or WhatsApp 0330 043 6250 or send the form. We will review your position and reply with a fixed-fee quote.
LPA Accountancy22 Milnpark St, Kinning Park
Glasgow G41 1BB
0141 459 3250 · WhatsApp 0330 043 6250
24/7 phone & WhatsApp support · Email replies within 24–72 hours